Yes, you can use cedar wood for cooking, but you need to use the right kind. The safest and most common option is food grade cedar, which is usually sold as grilling planks. This type of cedar is safe because it is untreated and made for direct contact with food.
Cedar adds a warm, smoky flavor to foods, especially fish, chicken, and veggies. If you have ever tried cedar plank salmon, that flavor comes from the wood itself. Before using a cedar plank, soak it in water for about 30 minutes. This keeps it from burning too fast and helps create steam that adds extra flavor.
One important thing to remember is to avoid using any cedar that has been painted, stained, or treated for building. Those chemicals can get into your food. Stick with cedar made for cooking to keep things safe.
To use a cedar plank, place your soaked board on a preheated grill, let it heat for a minute, then add your food on top. Cook as usual while keeping an eye on the plank. When the edges start to char, that is normal. It means the wood is doing its job.
Cedar cooking is simple, tasty, and a fun way to try something new in your kitchen.
What Type of Cedar Wood Is Safe For Cooking
Whenever someone asks me about using cedar for cooking, the first thing I tell them is this: not all cedar is safe. I learned this the hard way years ago when I grabbed a random cedar board from my shed thinking it was going to give my salmon some fancy smoky flavor. Instead, it made the whole backyard smell like a weird mix of perfume and chemicals. My food tasted awful, and honestly, I was nervous about even taking a bite. That was the day I realized how important it is to know the right type of cedar.
The safe cedar for cooking is called Western Red Cedar. This one has a clean, natural smell and does not release harmful stuff when heated. I remember the first time I used a real cooking plank made from Western Red Cedar. The wood hissed a little on the grill, the air filled with a warm woody smell, and the salmon I cooked on it came out with this gentle smoky flavor that felt almost sweet. That is when I understood why chefs love it.
There are other types of cedar like Eastern Red Cedar or White Cedar, but these are not good for cooking. They have strong natural oils and resins that can create a bitter taste in your food. Some even release toxins when heated, and trust me, you do not want that near your dinner. The thing that makes Western Red Cedar special is that it has a mild, food friendly aroma. It adds flavor without overpowering the food.
One thing I always tell beginners is to make sure the cedar is untreated. That means no varnish, no stains, no glue, and absolutely no shiny coating. If the plank looks perfect or polished, that is usually a bad sign. I once bought a pack of cheap cedar boards online, thinking I had found a great deal. When they arrived, the wood looked too smooth and had a strange smell. I took one look at it and said nope. I tossed them because there was no way I was putting my food on something that might have chemicals in it.
A good cedar plank should look natural. Sometimes it even has little knots or rough patches. That is totally normal. The natural, slightly rustic look is actually a good sign that the wood was not treated. When you pick it up, you should smell a fresh, clean woody scent. If it smells like paint or something sweet and artificial, that is usually a clue it has been treated.
Another thing to keep in mind is buying from trusted cooking brands. I used to think buying cedar at a home improvement store was the same as buying cooking planks, but it is not. Lumberyard cedar is made for fences and closets, not food. When you buy from brands that sell cooking planks, you can be sure the wood is safe, clean, and meant for grilling.
The more I cook with cedar, the more I realize how much the wood type affects the taste. I made one mistake years ago where I used a cedar scrap from an old furniture project. I thought sanding it down would make it safe, but the flavor that came out was so intense it felt like licking a pencil. Never again. Now I stick to Western Red Cedar only.
If you ever feel unsure, just remember this simple rule: if it is not labeled for cooking, do not use it. Western Red Cedar is the only type I trust, and as long as the plank is natural and untreated, you will get that perfect smoky flavor without any weird surprises.
How To Prepare Cedar Wood For Cooking
The first time I ever used a cedar plank, I threw it straight on the grill right out of the package. I had no idea you were supposed to prepare it. Within minutes, the whole plank caught fire and I ended up waving it around with my tongs like I was in some kind of cooking disaster movie. After that embarrassing moment, I finally learned how to get a cedar plank ready the right way, and honestly, it makes a huge difference in both safety and flavor.
The most important step is soaking the cedar plank in water. I usually soak mine for at least one hour. Some people soak it longer, even up to four hours, and that works too. The whole point of soaking is to keep the plank from burning too fast on the grill. When the wood is full of water, it gives off steam instead of flames, and that steam carries the cedar aroma into your food. You can even hold the plank under the water with something heavy because it tends to float. I normally put a clean plate on top of it to keep it submerged.
I like to use warm water because I feel like the wood absorbs it faster. Sometimes I add a splash of apple juice or lemon slices just for fun. I do not know if it actually makes a big difference, but the wood smells great while it soaks and the food seems a little brighter in flavor. One time I added white wine to the water because I was feeling fancy, but honestly, that was a waste of wine. Water is enough.
After soaking, I always rinse the plank quickly and give it a little scrub with my hand to remove any loose bits of wood. You do not want tiny splinters getting into your food. The plank should feel a bit heavier after soaking. That is how you know it has pulled in enough water.
Another thing I learned is that you can preheat the plank before putting food on it. Some people skip this step, but I like it because it helps release the cedar aroma faster. All I do is place the soaked plank on the grill for a couple of minutes until it starts to crackle slightly. The edges might turn a little dark, and that is totally normal. If it starts making loud popping noises, that means the heat is too high.
One mistake I used to make was brushing the plank with oil. I did it because it seemed like a normal cooking step, but oil heats up way too fast and can cause flare ups. I stopped doing that after the plank nearly turned into a torch. Now I only oil the food, not the wood.
You should also never use soap on your cedar plank. Soap can soak into the wood and leave behind flavors you absolutely do not want mixing with your food. Imagine tasting cedar plank salmon with a hint of dish soap. That is a disaster waiting to happen. Keep the cleaning simple and gentle.
If the plank looks dirty or dusty when you take it out of the package, do not panic. Sometimes the wood just sheds a little in the packaging. A quick rinse is all it needs. As long as the wood is untreated and natural, it is safe to use.
Once your plank is soaked, rinsed, and slightly preheated, it is ready for whatever you want to cook on it. Preparing the wood does not take long, but it can make a huge difference in both the flavor and the safety of your meal. I always feel more relaxed when I know the plank is properly soaked because I do not have to worry about sudden fires or burnt edges.
Over time, preparing cedar wood becomes second nature. You will know the plank is ready just by the way it feels and smells. It is one of those simple steps that helps every cedar cooking session go smoothly, even if you are not a grilling expert. And trust me, once you get the hang of it, you will love the way cedar adds flavor to your food.
Best Foods To Cook On Cedar Wood
When I first started cooking on cedar, I thought it was only for salmon because that is what everyone talks about. And yes, salmon on cedar is amazing, almost foolproof, but I soon realized there are so many other foods that taste incredible on a cedar plank. I kind of stumbled into this by accident one weekend when I had leftover vegetables and decided to toss them on the plank. The flavor surprised me in the best way. It was warm, slightly sweet, and honestly made me feel like I suddenly knew a lot more about grilling than I really did.
Salmon is still my favorite, though. The cedar adds a gentle smoky taste that blends perfectly with the natural richness of the fish. I remember one time I cooked a big salmon fillet for a family dinner. The cedar kept the fish super moist and prevented the bottom from sticking to the grill. I pulled the plank off the heat and everyone leaned in because the smell was incredible. That was the moment I knew cedar cooking was something I would use forever.
After salmon, the next food I tried was shrimp. Cedar grilled shrimp tastes way better than I expected, especially when you keep the seasoning simple. I usually add a little lemon, garlic, and salt. The cedar gives it this warm aroma that makes the shrimp feel almost fancy even though it cooks in just a few minutes. The trick is not to overcook them. I made that mistake once and ended up with little rubbery pieces that nobody wanted to eat. Now I watch them closely and pull them off as soon as they turn pink.
Vegetables on cedar might be the most underrated thing ever. Zucchini, mushrooms, potatoes, carrots, bell peppers, all of them get this soft woodsy flavor that you cannot get from foil or a pan. I love how the cedar steam keeps them moist so they do not burn too fast. One time I put asparagus on the plank just to see what would happen, and it tasted so good that it became a regular thing at my house. Even kids who normally fuss about veggies seem to like them more when they come off a cedar plank.
Chicken breast is another great option, but you need to keep an eye on it because the cedar flavor is strong. I usually marinate the chicken for an hour first, then let the plank do the rest. It comes out juicy every single time. The cedar helps hold the moisture in, which is a big deal because chicken dries out so easily. I once cooked a whole pack of chicken breasts on one plank for a backyard party and people kept asking what seasoning I used. I laughed because half the flavor came from the wood itself.
Some people even cook cheese on cedar, which sounds wild until you try it. A small wheel of brie melts into this creamy pool with a smoky edge that is perfect with crackers. I only tried it because a friend insisted, and now it is something I break out when I want to impress guests without doing a lot of work.
If there is one thing I have learned, it is that cedar cooking works best with foods that are mild. Anything too strong or spicy will drown out the wood flavor. Smooth, simple foods let the cedar shine. I also try to keep the plank close to the heat but not directly on top of flames so the food cooks gently.
Cedar cooking turns simple meals into something special without much effort. You do not need fancy tools or complicated recipes. Just good food, a soaked cedar plank, and a little patience. Once you try a few different foods, you will start finding your own favorites and maybe even create some signature dishes of your own.
Cedar Wood Cooking Methods
When I first started cooking with cedar, I thought there was only one way to do it. I just tossed the plank on the grill and hoped for the best. It worked sometimes, but other times I ended up with a burned plank, uneven cooking, or food that tasted a little too smoky. Over the years, I learned there are a few different ways to cook with cedar, and each method gives the food its own personality. Once I figured that out, everything got a whole lot easier and way more fun.
The most common method I use is grilling with a cedar plank. It is simple and gives the strongest cedar flavor. After soaking the plank, I lay it on the grill for a couple of minutes until it starts to crack just a little. Then I place the food directly on top. I love listening to that soft sizzle because it means the wood is steaming and not burning. One mistake I made early on was turning the heat up too high. The plank caught fire and I had to grab my spray bottle to control it. Now I keep the heat at medium and try to avoid flare ups by keeping the plank away from direct flames.
Another method that surprised me is cooking with cedar in the oven. It gives a more gentle flavor and feels a little more controlled. I like using the oven when I want the cedar aroma but do not want to deal with my grill. I usually set the oven to around 375 degrees and put the soaked plank on a baking sheet. Then I add whatever I am cooking and let the cedar do its thing. The steam fills the oven slowly, and the flavor is softer than grilling but still delicious. I once cooked salmon in the oven on cedar during a rainy day, and it tasted just as good as the grilled version without me having to run outside with an umbrella.
Sometimes I even use cedar on top of charcoal. This method took me a while to get right because charcoal burns hotter and sometimes unevenly. But when it works, the flavor is amazing. I let the charcoal settle until it turns gray, then place the plank on the cooler side of the grill. This indirect heat makes the cedar release a slow, steady steam that blends beautifully with the natural charcoal scent. One thing I learned is not to leave the plank unattended because charcoal can flare suddenly.
There is also a method where you place small cedar pieces or shavings in a smoker box, but I do not use that too often. It gives a stronger smoke that can be a little overpowering. I did it once with chicken and it tasted smoky enough to make my eyes water. I think cedar is better as a plank because it gives a cleaner, smoother taste. But if someone really wants a heavy cedar smoke, the smoker box can work. Just go easy on the wood or the flavor might take over the whole meal.
Heat control is the real secret in all these methods. Cedar works best when the heat is steady and not too aggressive. When I keep the heat at a medium level, the plank lasts longer and the food cooks more evenly. I also learned to keep a spray bottle of water nearby to handle tiny flare ups. It feels like a small thing, but it makes a big difference in keeping the plank from burning too fast.
Cooking with cedar is one of those techniques where the more you try different methods, the more confident you get. You start to learn how the wood behaves with different heat levels, how long it takes to steam, and how the flavor changes with each cooking style. For me, grilling is still the most exciting because it is hands on and full of aroma, but oven cooking is perfect when I want something easy and predictable.
No matter which method you use, cedar cooking brings a warm, natural flavor that makes even simple foods taste special. Once you figure out how to control the heat and pick the method that fits your meal, cedar becomes one of those tools you reach for again and again.
Safety Tips When Cooking With Cedar
When I talk to people about cooking with cedar, I always start with safety because it is one of those things you do not think about until something goes wrong. I learned that lesson the hard way when I used a random cedar board from my garage. It looked clean and smelled like wood, so I thought it was fine. But the moment it hit the heat, it gave off this sharp chemical smell that made me step back fast. Turned out the board had been treated years ago, and I only realized it after I looked closely and saw a slight shine on the surface. Ever since then, I am extra careful about making sure the cedar is safe.
The first rule is to only use cedar that is natural and untreated. That means no stains, no oils, no glues, and no finishes. You would be surprised how many cedar boards look natural but actually have small amounts of chemicals in them. I always inspect the wood closely before using it. If the plank looks overly smooth or shiny, that is usually a sign that it has been treated. Safe cooking cedar should smell like clean wood and nothing else.
Another important thing I learned is to watch the heat. Cedar can catch fire pretty quickly if the grill is too hot. I remember one time the edges of my plank started burning, and I panicked because I thought my whole dinner was ruined. Luckily, I had a spray bottle of water next to the grill. Now I never start cedar cooking without having one ready. A quick mist is all it takes to calm the flames without soaking the food.
Ventilation is another big deal. Cedar gives off a natural aroma, but that smell is meant to float away outdoors or move around in an oven with space. One time I tried to use a cedar plank on a small indoor electric grill. The smoke filled the kitchen fast and set off the smoke alarm. It was a total mess. After that, I only use cedar on outdoor grills or in a full sized oven where the air can circulate properly. It keeps the smoke at a safe level and makes the cooking process feel a lot calmer.
Temperature control is also important for safety. I used to blast the grill to high heat thinking it would make the food cook faster, but all it did was burn the edges of the plank and dry the food out. Now I keep the grill at medium heat most of the time because cedar works best with steady heat. It helps the wood release its flavor slowly instead of burning all at once.
You should also be careful when handling the plank after cooking. The wood gets incredibly hot and stays that way longer than you think. I once grabbed a cedar plank with thin tongs and it slipped and almost hit my foot. Now I always use thicker tongs or heat gloves and make sure I have a safe spot to set the plank down when it comes off the grill. Hot cedar can leave burn marks on counters, so I usually place it on a metal tray or cutting board.
Another safety tip is to keep an eye on splinters. Cedar is a soft wood, and sometimes tiny pieces can loosen when it heats up. Before putting the food on the plank, I always run my hand lightly over the surface to check for rough patches. If I feel anything sharp, I sand it down quickly or use another plank. Nobody wants a splinter hiding under their salmon.
And something most people do not think about is how the cedar actually ages. After a few uses, the plank becomes darker, more brittle, and sometimes starts to warp. That is normal, but once it gets too charred or cracks too much, it is safer to throw it away. I tried using an old plank once, and it broke in half while cooking. That was a good reminder that cedar does not last forever and should be replaced before it becomes a problem.
Cooking with cedar is fun and flavorful, but staying safe makes the whole process smooth. Once you get used to checking your planks, watching the heat, and handling the wood carefully, cedar cooking becomes something you can enjoy with confidence every time.
How To Reuse or Dispose of Cedar Cooking Planks
When I first started using cedar planks, I assumed they were single use. I would cook something on the plank, enjoy the smoky flavor, and then toss the whole thing in the trash without thinking twice. But after a few uses, I realized those planks were not cheap, and I started wondering if I could actually reuse them. So I experimented a bit, and it turns out you can reuse cedar planks sometimes, but it depends on how they look after cooking. I learned that the wood tells you when it has had enough.
The first thing I look at after cooking is the bottom of the plank. If it is heavily charred or looks like it has survived a small fire, then that plank is pretty much done. There is no saving it. But if the plank only has light burn marks and still feels solid, I usually rinse it off and use it again. I do not use soap because soap can soak into the wood and mess up the flavor next time, so I just scrub the surface gently with a brush and warm water. The key is to clean it right after cooking so the oils and juices do not soak in too deeply.
One thing I noticed is that the first use always gives the strongest cedar flavor. By the second or third use, the flavor becomes softer. It is still there, just not as intense. I actually like this for vegetables because the lighter cedar smell keeps the veggies from getting overwhelmed. I remember cooking shrimp on a reused plank once and thinking the flavor was perfect because it was not too strong. It felt balanced in a way the fresh plank sometimes is not.
But even if the plank looks reusable, there are limits. After two or three uses, the wood can start to crack or warp. I made the mistake of trying to squeeze a fourth use out of an old plank, and it broke right in the middle of cooking. The food slid off, and I knew right then I had pushed it too far. Now I always check for cracks before reusing a plank. If it bends too easily or feels brittle, I toss it.
When it comes to disposal, cedar planks are pretty simple. Since they are natural untreated wood, they can be composted in most places. I usually break them into smaller pieces and throw them into my compost pile. The wood breaks down slowly but still eventually turns into soil. It feels good knowing the plank goes back to the earth instead of sitting in a landfill. If you do not have compost, you can throw it in the regular trash. Just make sure it has cooled down completely because hot wood can start fires.
I have also seen people get creative and use old cedar planks for crafts. I tried this once by sanding a plank and turning it into a little herb sign for the garden. It looked rustic and smelled nice for a while. Another time I used a worn out plank to help start a campfire. It caught flame quickly and burned clean, which made it a useful backup fire starter. Just make sure the plank you repurpose is not soaked with old food juices because that can smell strange when burned.
Another thing I learned is to avoid reusing a plank if the food cooked on it was heavily seasoned or covered in sugary sauce. Sauces can soak into the wood and cause the plank to smoke too much or burn unevenly on the next use. I had this happen when I made a sweet glaze on salmon. The next time I used the plank, that soaked in sugar turned sticky and gave off a burnt smell. After that, I got more selective about which planks I reuse.
Cedar planks have a pretty simple life cycle. New, then lightly used, then ready to retire. When you know what to look for, it becomes easy to decide when to reuse and when to toss. And honestly, reusing planks can be a nice way to save money while still getting that great cedar flavor. Just pay attention to how the wood looks and feels, and you will get the hang of it faster than you think.
Cedar vs Other Cooking Woods
When I first got into wood plank cooking, I honestly thought cedar was the only wood people used. It was the one everyone talked about, especially for salmon, so I stuck with it. But after a few years of grilling and messing around with different flavors, I started trying other woods like apple, hickory, oak, and alder. That is when I realized how different each wood can make a meal taste. It is almost like using different spices. Some woods are bold, some are gentle, and some are so strong they can knock you out if you are not careful.
Cedar is one of the most unique woods because it has this warm, sweet, almost spicy smell when it heats up. It works best with foods that are simple or mild because the cedar flavor can take the lead pretty fast. Salmon loves cedar. You can put a plain salmon fillet on a cedar plank with just a pinch of salt, and it tastes like you spent hours working on it. I love using cedar for vegetables too, especially mushrooms and potatoes, because it gives them a comforting aroma. But cedar is a soft wood, and that means it burns faster and has a stronger aroma than some other woods. If someone wants something subtle, cedar is not always the right choice.
Alder, on the other hand, is super gentle. When I first tried alder, I almost thought it was not working because the scent was so light. But then I tasted the fish I cooked on it, and it had this clean, slightly sweet flavor that did not scream smoke but still made everything taste more interesting. Alder is one of the safest woods to experiment with because it will not overpower your food. I use it when I want something mellow and smooth. It is a great match for white fish and chicken.
Then there is applewood. Apple is fruity and soft, almost like a sweet perfume. I use it when I want a calm smoke flavor without anything too strong. Applewood does not usually come in plank form where I live, so I use it more for smoking or grilling with small chips. One time I used applewood chips with a cedar plank at the same time just to see what would happen. The mix gave the food a layered flavor, kind of like combining two seasonings. It turned out surprisingly good.
Hickory is a whole different story. Hickory is bold. It is the kind of wood that tastes like barbecue restaurants and big backyard cookouts. The first time I used hickory, I did not know how strong it was. I put a thick chicken breast on the grill with hickory chunks and ended up with a flavor so smoky it almost felt like eating a campfire. Some people love that strong taste, but for me, hickory is best used in small amounts. I would never pair hickory with fish the way I do with cedar. Hickory will cover up everything else and leave you wondering if you actually seasoned your food.
Oak is the middle ground. It is steady, balanced, and not too sweet or too strong. I like oak when I want something consistent. Oak gives a classic smoke flavor that works well with pretty much anything, especially beef and pork. It is not as bold as hickory and not as sweet as applewood. You could say it is the quiet professional of cooking woods.
Once I started testing different woods, I realized cedar sits in its own category. It is not like the fruit woods or the hardwoods. It has a unique aroma that only cedar can give. It is bold but not like hickory. It is sweet but not like applewood. It is somewhere in between, with its own personality. And when used right, it can create flavors you cannot get from any other wood.
Each wood has its own role. Cedar is perfect for giving moisture and strong aroma to foods like salmon and shrimp. Alder works great for gentle flavors. Applewood gives a soft, fruity smoke. Oak gives a balanced taste. Hickory is for hardcore smoky meals. Once you cook with each one a few times, you start noticing the differences right away. I even keep small notes in a notebook about what worked, what did not, and what combinations surprised me.
Comparing cedar to other woods taught me how much wood choice affects everything. It is kind of addicting once you get into it. And the best part is experimenting. When you cook with different woods, you learn more about your own taste too. You start discovering which flavors make you smile and which ones feel like too much. That is when cooking stops feeling like work and starts feeling like a hobby you cannot wait to get back to.
Common Mistakes When Cooking With Cedar
I wish someone had handed me a list of common mistakes when I started cooking with cedar, because I made almost every one you can think of. Looking back, I laugh at some of the things I did, but at the time I was frustrated and confused about why my food tasted bitter or why my plank kept catching fire. Cedar cooking is simple once you get the hang of it, but the early mistakes can really mess things up if you do not know what to watch out for.
The biggest mistake I made in the beginning was using dry cedar. I did not know the plank had to be soaked. I had seen pictures online of cedar planks on grills, so I just copied the idea without reading the instructions. I tossed a dry plank on high heat, and within seconds it looked like a campfire. Flames everywhere. I had to grab the plank with tongs and drop it into a bucket of water. After that, I learned that soaking the plank for at least an hour is not optional. The water helps the wood steam instead of burning and gives that perfect cedar aroma.
Another mistake I made was using treated cedar without realizing it. I once used a random cedar board that had been sitting in my garage. At first it smelled normal, but as soon as heat hit it, the scent changed to something sharp and chemical. That was the moment I understood the importance of using only untreated cooking grade cedar. If the plank has any kind of finish or coating, it is not safe. I always tell people to check for shiny surfaces or strong smells before using a plank. If anything seems off, do not use it.
One mistake that took me a while to fix was overheating the grill. I used to think more heat meant faster cooking and stronger flavor, but cedar does not work like that. High heat makes the plank burn too fast and gives the food a bitter or burnt taste. I ruined a whole batch of chicken this way one summer. Now I keep the heat at medium or medium low, letting the plank heat slowly. It takes a little more patience, but the flavor comes out cleaner and smoother.
Placing the plank directly over flames is another rookie mistake I made. When the flame touches the plank, it can scorch and create a harsh taste. I used to think cedar was supposed to burn a little, but that is not true. The wood should smolder and steam, not catch fire. Once I learned to put the plank over indirect heat, everything got easier. The wood lasted longer and the food cooked more evenly.
I also used to forget to season the food properly. For some reason I assumed the cedar alone would add enough flavor, so I would put plain chicken or plain vegetables on the plank. The cedar does add flavor, but the food still needs seasoning. A little salt, pepper, and maybe lemon or garlic helps bring everything together. The cedar enhances the flavors instead of replacing them.
One funny mistake I made was cutting the plank into smaller pieces thinking it would make it last longer. All it did was make it burn faster because the heat concentrated on a smaller surface. I learned to use the full plank and let the food sit in the center where the heat is most stable.
Another mistake is reusing planks that are too damaged. I used to squeeze as many uses out of a plank as possible, even when it was warped or cracked. One day, the plank split in half on the grill, and half my salmon slid right off. That was the day I accepted that sometimes it is better to retire a plank than to risk ruining dinner.
People also forget to watch for splinters. Cedar is soft, and sometimes little pieces come loose after heating. I run my hand over the plank before using it to make sure the surface is smooth. It takes two seconds and saves a lot of trouble.
One of the smaller mistakes I made was not using a spray bottle. Flare ups happen, even when you are careful. A quick spray keeps the plank from burning too quickly. Once I started keeping a spray bottle nearby, I felt way more relaxed when grilling.
The truth is, most cedar cooking mistakes come from heat, the wrong type of wood, or not soaking properly. Once you fix those, everything else becomes pretty simple. And even if you mess up, the good news is you learn fast. Cedar cooking is forgiving once you understand the basics. After a few tries, you will feel like a pro and start enjoying the process instead of worrying about what might go wrong.
Buying Guide For Cedar Cooking Planks
When I first went out to buy cedar planks, I thought it would be simple. I figured I could walk into any store, grab something that said cedar, and get grilling. But the choices were all over the place. Different sizes, different thicknesses, different colors, and a lot of them were not even meant for cooking. I made a few mistakes buying the wrong kind of cedar, and a couple of those mistakes ended with me throwing away whole packages because the wood smelled strange or looked treated. After a while, I learned what to look for and what to avoid, and now buying planks feels almost as easy as picking out vegetables.
The first thing I check is whether the cedar is labeled specifically for cooking. If the package does not say grilling or cooking anywhere on it, I walk away. Wood meant for closets, fences, or crafts might look similar but can be treated with chemicals you do not want near your food. I learned this the hard way when I bought cheap cedar boards from a hardware store thinking I got a deal. When I opened the pack, they had a weird shiny layer that felt almost waxy. I did not trust them, so they went straight into the trash.
Western Red Cedar is the safest and most common cedar used for cooking. When I see that name on the packaging, I feel a lot more confident. It has the flavor you want and does not release anything harmful when heated. I also try to buy planks that have a natural wood smell. If the wood smells too sweet, too sharp, or like chemicals, that is usually a warning sign. Safe cedar should smell clean and woody.
Thickness is another thing I pay attention to. Thin planks look cheaper and sometimes cook fine, but they burn fast and usually do not last long. I like planks that are around a half inch thick because they hold up better on the grill and can sometimes be reused. I once bought a super thin pack that warped the second it hit the heat. The food slid around, the plank charred almost immediately, and it barely lasted one cooking session. After that, I decided thicker is better.
The size of the plank matters too. I try to pick planks that are big enough for the food I cook most often. For salmon, I buy longer planks so the whole fillet fits without hanging off the sides. For veggies or shrimp, smaller planks work just fine. One time I bought planks that were too small for the salmon, and the edges of the fish ended up cooking directly over the grill grates. It messed up the texture and took away the even cedar flavor. Since then, I always check the measurements on the package.
Another thing I learned to look at is whether the wood has knots or cracks. A few knots are not a big deal, but if the plank looks like it is already splitting, it will probably fall apart on the grill. I made that mistake once, and the plank cracked in the middle while cooking. Now I take a quick look for even grain and sturdiness before buying.
Brand is something I pay attention to now more than I used to. Some brands use better quality planks that are thicker, smoother, and more consistent. I remember buying a no name pack online because it was cheap, and when it arrived, the wood was rough and splintery. Ever since then, I stick with brands that clearly label their planks as food safe and meant for grilling.
I also avoid planks that look too perfect. If the wood is extremely smooth and uniform in color, it sometimes means the plank has been processed or treated. Natural cedar usually has small grain patterns, tiny color shifts, and an earthy smell. That imperfect look is actually a good thing.
When buying online, I always check the reviews. People love to talk about grilling, and if a plank is bad quality, the reviews will say it. I once bought a pack after ignoring the reviews and regretted it immediately because the planks arrived damp and moldy. Now I always check what people say before adding anything to my cart.
Buying cedar planks gets easier once you know what to look for. Natural, untreated, Western Red Cedar is the main thing. A good thickness, the right size, and a safe brand make a huge difference. With the right plank, the food tastes better, the cooking is easier, and the experience is way more fun. It is one of those little details that sounds small but makes everything else go smoother.
Conclusion
Cooking with cedar has become one of those things I never get tired of because it adds so much flavor with so little effort. When I first tried it, I made plenty of mistakes, but once I learned the basics like choosing the right type of cedar, soaking the plank, and keeping the heat steady, everything changed. The food tasted better, the cooking felt easier, and I actually looked forward to trying new recipes. Cedar gives this warm, smoky aroma that makes even simple meals feel a little special.
The best part is that cedar cooking is not hard once you understand how it works. You just need the right plank, some patience, and a little practice. Whether you are making salmon, shrimp, vegetables, or even chicken, the cedar helps keep the food moist and full of flavor. And if you ever get unsure about something, it usually comes back to the same tips we talked about. Use natural untreated Western Red Cedar, soak it well, avoid high heat, and pay attention to how the plank looks after each use.
I hope all the stories and lessons help you feel more confident when you try cedar cooking on your own. It is a fun way to bring new flavors into your kitchen or backyard, and once you get the hang of it, you might even find a few favorite dishes of your own. If you experiment with different foods or discover a cool trick, share it with others. You never know who might learn from your experience. Happy cooking!