If your potatoes feel a little soft but don’t smell bad or have mold, they’re usually still safe to eat. Just cut away any sprouts or wrinkly spots before cooking.
Potatoes can get soft when they’ve been sitting too long or stored in a warm place. As long as they don’t feel mushy, slimy, or smell rotten, they’re likely fine. Sprouts are common too. They look like little roots growing out of the potato. You can snap them off and toss them.
Now, if the whole potato feels squishy or has green patches, it’s better to throw it out. That green color means it’s started to produce a toxin that can upset your stomach. Same goes for mold or a strong bad smell. That’s a clear sign it’s time for the trash.
To keep potatoes fresh longer, store them in a cool, dark place. Not the fridge though. Cold temps can change the flavor and make them too sweet.
In short, a little softness is okay. But if your potato smells off, looks green, or feels mushy, it’s not worth the risk. When in doubt, toss it out.
Is It Safe to Eat Sprouted Potatoes? | Dietitian Q&A | EatingWell
Potatoes soften over time due to a natural aging process. They lose moisture, which causes them to become less firm and shriveled. This happens to all potatoes, whether they’re stored for a few weeks or a few months. But the rate at which they soften can depend on several factors:
- Storage Conditions: Potatoes kept in a warm or humid environment will soften faster than those stored in a cool, dry place.
- Potato Variety: Different potato varieties have varying shelf lives. For instance, russets (a starchy type) generally last longer than waxy potatoes like red or new potatoes.
- Sprouting and Softness: Potatoes often sprout as they age. While the sprouts themselves aren’t dangerous, they indicate that the potato is getting old. You can easily remove the sprouts, but the softness means it’s closer to its expiration date.
When Are Soft Potatoes Still Safe to Eat?
Despite the natural softening process, soft potatoes are still edible in many cases. Here are some signs to look for when soft potatoes are still safe to eat:
- Slightly Soft but Firm Inside: If the potato feels soft on the outside but is still firm when you cut into it, it’s probably fine. You can peel away any soft or shriveled skin, and the flesh inside should still be good for cooking.
- Small Sprouts Are Okay: It’s common for potatoes to sprout after some time. Small sprouts are not harmful, as long as you remove them before eating. Just make sure to discard any green spots, which contain solanine.
- Proper Storage: If the potato has been stored in a cool, dark place (like a pantry) and doesn’t have any strange smells or colors, it’s safe to eat. Potatoes stored properly can last much longer than those kept in the fridge or exposed to heat.
- No Green Color: A potato that has a greenish tint should be avoided, as that’s a sign of solanine buildup, which can cause nausea or headaches. If there’s no green, and the potato still feels firm, it’s generally safe.
Signs That Soft Potatoes Are No Longer Safe to Eat
Even though soft potatoes can often be saved, there are times when they’ve gone beyond the point of no return. Here’s when it’s best to toss them:
- Mushy and Squishy Texture: If the potato is so soft that it feels mushy or squishy when you press it, it’s likely spoiled. You should also avoid any potato that is leaking moisture or looks waterlogged.
- Green Color and Bitter Taste: Green patches are a sign of solanine, which makes the potato bitter and unsafe to eat in large amounts. If the potato has turned green and soft, it’s best to throw it away.
- Off Smell: Fresh potatoes have an earthy smell. If you notice a sour or rotten odor, it’s a clear sign that the potato has gone bad and should be discarded.
- Excessive Sprouting: While small sprouts are okay, large, thick sprouts or multiple sprouts are a sign the potato is far too old and likely not worth eating anymore.
How to Store Potatoes to Prevent Softness
Proper storage is key to extending the shelf life of potatoes and preventing them from softening too quickly. Here are some tips to ensure your potatoes last longer:
- Keep Them in a Cool, Dark Place: The ideal storage temperature for potatoes is between 45-50°F (7-10°C). A cool pantry or cupboard is perfect, as long as it’s away from direct sunlight.
- Avoid Refrigeration: While it may seem like refrigerating potatoes would prolong their life, it actually causes the starch in potatoes to convert to sugar. This can lead to an off-sweet flavor and a change in texture. The best storage option is a pantry, not the fridge.
- Proper Ventilation: Potatoes need airflow to stay fresh. Keep them in a well-ventilated space, such as a mesh bag or a breathable cardboard box, to prevent excess moisture from building up.
- Don’t Store with Onions: Onions and potatoes should never be stored together. The gases emitted by onions can cause potatoes to sprout or spoil more quickly.
Conclusion
So, can you eat soft potatoes? Yes, but with a few caveats. Soft potatoes are usually still fine to eat if they haven’t developed green spots, off smells, or excessive mushiness. Just remember to remove any soft or sprouted parts before cooking.
And if you’re storing them at home, keeping them in a cool, dry place is key to prolonging their shelf life. Now, you don’t have to stress about soft potatoes anymore! Just give them a quick check, and if they pass the test, cook away!